Ok, so I have both a crappy amp, a crappy guitar, and some pretty good pedals.
This is My Setup:
-Guitar: Beat up Squier Bullet with a Gibson Faded Flying V stock humbucker in the bridge.
-Amp: Fender Frontman 212r (old version) with a broken channel switch. Only works when the footpedal is plugged in.
- Pedals: EHX Small Stone, Small Clone, Memory Boy. Dunlop Original Crybaby, and Devi Ever Rocket Fuzz.

What I need help deciding, is whether I should buy a new guitar or a new amp? I would like both, of course, but money is a bit tight.

The Guitar I am considering is either a Fender Jaguar HH or Jazzmaster. and the amp, a used Fender Twin Reverb.
Thanks

My Budget is around $1000, probably a bit less. The sounds I'm trying to get are some that are heavy with fuzz, sound great clean, but are also good for noisy experimentation.

Also, would a Peavey Valveking be a good amp choice?

What's your budget and what is the sound you are going for.

From looking at your pedals and current gear, I would make the following assumptions that you might like these.

Fender '72 reissue Telecaster Custom

Fender Classic Player Jazzmaster


Peavey Classic 30

Vox Ac 15

Fender Blues Jr.

__________________
Messy Bedroom Luxe & Reduxe

Good exchange with Cham Clowder.

The Fender Jaguar Classic Player HH is a wonderful guitar and I've always loved mine, but as soon as I got it home and put it through my Fender Frontman, it sounded like any other guitar through the same amp, be it a Squier or a PRS. I only realised what a difference the amp makes when I started playing through Orange Tiny Terrors at high volumes, which kicks the crap out of my Frontman! I think Messy Bedroom is spot on with gear ideas, since he's listed great amps at low prices! I can vouch for the Peavey Classic 30 stack, which I love for it's country cleans and bluesy overdrive!

__________________
Rickenbacker 330/Gibson Les Paul Standard and a couple of amps, depending on how long the walk to the place is.

FS: Fender Telecaster Contemporary, Orange Thunder 30, Mesa Boogie Studio Preamp, Fender Vibro Champ.